If you’re looking to buy a new play yard mattress and still confused about which one is best.

Then you’re in the right place because Our team has spent more than 50 hours researching, comparing, and testing the different options available in the market nowadays to be able to compile the following list of picks for the best play yard mattress you can purchase right away from Amazon.

First, here are our picks for today along with our research score for each item.

Top 10 best play yard mattress (Our Favorites)

Now, let’s take a look at each item of the best play yard mattress, in order to know the different features & benefits of each pick.

hiccapop Pack and Play Pad [Dual Sided] w/Firm Side (for Babies) & Soft Memory Foam Side (for Toddlers) | Memory Foam Play Yard Pad | Playard Pad Foam for Pack and Play Fits (38"x26")

$69.99
$59.92
 in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • PACK N PLAY COMPATIBLE - NO GAPS - FITS ALL 38” x 26” PLAYARDS PERFECTLY | Rounded corners and superior edge support create a snug fit into all 38” x 26” play yards every time. No risk of unsafe spaces or lost pacifiers, toys, or stuffed animals at the sides or corners of this playard pad. IMPORTANT: PLAYARDS COME IN MANY SIZES. The hiccapop pack and play pad is specifically designed for 38” x 26” playards ONLY.
  • THE ONLY DUAL-SIDED FOAM FOR PACK AND PLAY | Optimal design for your growing baby’s developmental needs. Infant side offers the firmness that’s critical for newborns. And for toddlers, simply flip over to the plush, softer side featuring our CertiPUR-USA high-density memory foam for a softer play surface.
  • EXTRA THICK FOR SUPER COMFORT | Your sweet baby will not be a happy camper (nor will you) if her play yard pad lacks vital support and comfort when playing or even standing. That’s why our pack and play foam pad is 3.25” thick to offer deeper and more supportive comfort for your baby’s enjoyment during play or quiet time.
  • LEAK-FREE, SUPER SAFE | Our ultra-soft Jacquard cover is waterproof and hypoallergenic, with lock stitched binding to resist liquids and stains. Our high-quality zipper permits easy removal for machine washing and drying.
  • HIGHEST STANDARDS | hiccapop is dedicated to providing families with products of the highest quality and safety. Our CertiPUR-USA seal of protection guarantees that our Dual Sided Pack and Play pad has met the most rigorous and comprehensive standards for content and durability.

Vibe bear 3" Premium Foam Pack and Play Mattress 38x26x3 -Quiet and odorless Playard Mattress,Portable Crib Mattress,Play Yard Mattress Fits (38"x26") Pack N Play Playpens,Pack n Play Mattresses

$39.99
$36.99
 in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • Fits all 38" x 26"playards. Vibe Bear pack n play mattresses (38" x 26" x 3") uses handcrafted techniques to make the edges more dimensional, full and secure. Rounded corners and superior edge support create a snug fit into all 38" x 26"portable cribs every time. Important: playards come in many sizes. Please measure your crib first to ensure a perfect fit.
  • Safety assured. Vibe bear pack n play mattress is CPSC tested and passes all flammability tests - 16 CFR 1632 ,1633, phthalate, lead and toxicity tests.
  • Sweet sleep. Whether it's lying down or rolling on the pack n play mattresses,there is no sound. The mattress for pack and play provides your child with enough support and comfort to reduces tossing and turning, and ensures a more restful and less interrupted.
  • Designed for babies. Not too hard or too soft, Vibe Bear playpen mattresses is developed according to the characteristics of baby's bone development, perfectly fit for babies and effectively support babies, where babies have been lying without causing dent, which is very safe.
  • No odor. Most playpen mattresses emit pungent odors when removed from their original packaging, and these odors can be unpleasant. To be honestly,the Vibe bear portable crib mattress has no pungent odor. We cares about you and your little one, so If you have any problems, you can return it whenever you want.

Dream On Me 3” Square Corner Playmat / Playtime comfort/ Reinforced waterproof cover/ Greenguard Gold environment safe playmat

$37.99
$32.29
 in stock
5 new from $32.29
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • THE SAFE CHOICE: Keeping in mind the health & safety of your baby, this playmat is not only Greenguard Gold & JPMA certified but also complies with the Federal Flammability Standard 16 CFR 1633.
  • APPEALING COVER: The wonderful Dream On Me 3” Square Corner Playmat has a durable vinyl cover with an adorable cloud print.
  • EASY MAINTENANCE: With a reinforced waterproof cover and binding that resists liquids & stains, the Dream On Me 3” Square Corner Playmat is super easy to clean with just mild soap and warm water.
  • PRODUCT SPECS: Product dimensions are 38” L x 25.5” W x 3” H, with a weight of 3.5 Lbs.
  • PRODUCT WARNINGS: The Dream On Me 3” Square Corner Playmat is intended to be used for babies 6 months and older.

Dream On Me 3” Foam Playmat/Ideal Comfort & Support/Waterproof Vinyl Cover/Greenguard Gold Environment Safe playmat

$39.04  in stock
3 new from $39.04
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • FIRM & COMFY SUPPORT: This superior quality playmat features a firm foam core, offering a perfect balance of comfort and support.
  • HEALTHY BABY ENVIRONMENT: To create a healthy indoor environment for your baby, the Dream On Me 3” Foam Playmat is Greenguard Gold certified.
  • THE SAFE CHOICE: The Dream On Me 3” Foam Playmat ensures the highest level of safety for your child, as it meets the Federal Flammability Standard 16 CFR 1632.
  • EASY MAINTENANCE: This exceptional mattress is manufactured with quality materials and workmanship in the USA, featuring a waterproof cover that wipes clean with mild soap and water easily.
  • PRODUCT SPECS: Product dimensions are 38” L x 25.5” W x 3” H, with a weight of 3.5 Lbs.

Waterproof Pack and Play Mattress Pad 38" x 26", Bamboo Dual Sided (Firm for Babies) & Soft Foam (for Toddlers) Breathable Playard Mattress Topper, Foam Baby Playpen/Play Yard Mattresses

$36.99  in stock
1 used from $35.14
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • Comfortable Sleeping: Smooth bamboo jacquard surface, naturally, breathable cover is skin-friendly for baby and made up with high density foam, it designed with air bleed to effective airflow and reduce body heat, SPRINGSPIRIT playard mattress topper will perfectly balance between firm support and soft comfort. Measures 38 x 26 inch with rounded corners to make sure the mattress for pack and play can perfectly universal fit.
  • Dual Comfort Playard Mattress: Dual-sided playard crib mattress provides firm side (white side) to be harder support for infants,this side is constructed of high density foam with optimal firmness, flat surface—Just what babies need to support their growing bones & reduce hazard when they learn to move. And soft gel-infused foam (blue side) for toddlers, It provides a cozy environment for better sleep.
  • Non-slip Backing Design: Playard mattress with non-skid gripping dots ensure the mattress stays in place. Since the product can be also used without a playard as well for the perfect baby sleeping mat.
  • Removable and Waterproof Zippered Cover: Removable soft OEKO-TEX standard 100 certified cover with smooth bamboo surface and TPU waterproof layer that can be washable and extremely soft to the touch for your baby, you never have to worry about accidents and keeping your mattress clean.
  • SPRINGSPIRIT'S Life-time Guarantee: Quality you can trust, if the playpen mattress topper for pack and play does not meet your needs for any reason,replacement or money back,no questions asked. After you received the product, Please allow 24 to 48 hours for topper to expand.

Milliard Tri-Fold Pack N' Play Mattress - Plus Free Bonus Carry Case

$49.99  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • Sleep In Comfort – help your child sleep better by replacing the thin, hard mattress that comes with the pack-n-play. Constructed from top quality, high density foam, this mattress provides the perfect balance between firm support and soft comfort so your little one can sleep better - and you can too!
  • Maximum Portability – Milliard original trifold design allows you to easily fold up your mattress into the bonus carry bag that’s included for free - so you can easily store or travel with your mattress. It can be used without a playard as well for the perfect toddler sleeping mat.
  • Waterproof Cover – comes with a top-quality, polyester cover that’s both waterproof and washable so you never have to worry about keeping your mattress clean.
  • Lab Tested – our topper's foam meets CertiPUR-US standards for content, emissions and durability, and are analyzed by independent, accredited testing laboratories.
  • More Details - soft mattress is not intended for babies. Consult with physician for safety recommendations. Measures 38x26x1.5 with rounded corners for a perfect universal fit. Please allow 24 to 48 hours for foam to expand after opening.

Pack and Play Mattress Topper 38" x 26", Bamboo Dual Sided (Firm for Babies) & Soft Foam (for Toddlers) Breathable Playard Mattress Pad, Foam Baby Playpen/Play Yard Mattress

$39.99  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • Cozy & Soft Surface: Smooth bamboo jacquard surface, naturally, breathable cover is skin-friendly for baby and measures 38 x 26 inch with rounded corners to make sure pack and play mattress can perfectly universal fit.
  • Breathable & Cozy Dual Sided Mattress: Integrated with gel foam and high-density support foam, the firmer flat and even surface promotes proper support for infant, slightly softer foam side provides maximum comfort for toddler. The playard mattress is engineered to optimize air flow and reduce trapped body heat, giving your baby a cool and comfortable sleep environment, make your baby sleep more comfortably.
  • Non-slip Bottom Structure: The non-slip gripping dots ensure the mattress stays in place, It's best protection at daycare time even if your little one is rolling or playing on playard crib mattress. Since the product can be also used without a playard as well for the perfect baby sleeping mat.
  • Removable and Waterproof Zippered Cover: Removable soft OEKO-TEX standard 100 certified cover with smooth bamboo surface and waterproof layer is made of food-grade TPU that won't make a crinkly plastic noise when your baby moves, and against everyday liquids and stains. It's extremely soft to the touch for your baby, you never have to worry about accidents and keeping your mattress clean.
  • Biloban's Life-time Guarantee: Quality you can trust, if the playard mattress topper does not meet your needs for any reason,replacement or money back,no questions asked. After you received the product, Please allow 24 to 48 hours for topper to expand.

Waterproof Pack N Play Mattress Pad Protector, Cotton Fabric Absorbent and Soft Pack and Play Sheets, Fits Baby Portable Mini Cribs, Graco Play Yards and Foldable Mini Crib Mattress Sheets Cover

$17.98
$15.89
 in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • Comfortable Fabric and Quiet Design: 100% durable and skin friendly cotton surface, perfect for your baby's sensitive skin. inner down alternative fiber filling increases absorbency, and the middle use waterproof layer prevents leaking. And the extra bottom fabric back offers extra protection. Four layers design ensure the mini crib mattress cover provide a quiet sleep or play environment.
  • Ultimate Protection:Use the premium waterproof membrane is durable and breathable that protects your baby from no matter what kind of liquid may come. Moreover, this mattress pad protector /mattress pad cover is vinyl-free and ideal for your children.
  • Softness and absorbent filling: The quilted design and optimum padding of our pack n play mattress pad protector give just the right amount of softness and support for your baby to sleep or play. And we use extra comfortable filling that can also absorbs any liquids almost instantly and the fully waterproof lining protects your expensive mattress.
  • Perfectly Fit: The mattress pad protector dimension 27 x 39 x 5 inches, this waterproof mattress cover designed specifically for the pack n play mattress(38"x 26"), mini/portable crib mattress (38"x24") or a foldable playard mattress, including fit for Graco pack n play, Dream on Me or hiccapop pack and play mattress, Papablic pack and play mattress, portable mini crib mattress. If you have a this kind mini mattress, This mini crib mattress protector is a must.
  • Moonsea Guarantee: As cotton fabric may shrink after washing, we specially enlarged the size when we produced it, so it may be a little big when you received it, but will be more suitable after washing. The product quality you can trust so you can buy at ease. If there is any problem with our pack n play mattress pad cover, please contact us and we can replace for you or money back without excuses.

Dream On Me On-The-Go Trifold Playmat / Excellent Support / Easy To Store With Carry Bag/ Greenguard Gold Environment Safe Playmat

$39.99  in stock
2 new from $39.99
2 used from $17.21
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • EXCELLENT SUPPORT: Safe, convenient and mobile, this perfect playmat offers a firm fiber core foundation and excellent support for your baby.
  • A HEALTHY BABY ENVIRONMENT: The Dream On Me On-The-Go Trifold Playmat creates a healthy indoor environment for your child as it is Greenguard Gold certified.
  • SAFETY FIRST: The Dream On Me On-The-Go Trifold Playmat is JPMA Certified and tested to pass all flammability tests (16 CFR 1632 /1633) assuring maximum safety.
  • EASY TO STORE & CLEAN: The Dream On Me On-The-Go Trifold Playmat folds compactly in the free carry bag provided. Simply unfold and use! This playmat also comes with a waterproof cover that easily wipes clean with warm water and mild soap.
  • PRODUCT SPECS: Product dimensions are 38” L x 25.5” W x 2” H with a weight of 2 Lbs

Nicesure Dual Sided Pack and Play Mattress Firm Side (for Babies) & Soft Memory Foam Side (for Toddlers) Playpen Playyard Pad Fits (38"x26")

$45.99  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2022 6:07 pm

Features

  • PACK N PLAY COMPATIBLE: Fits all 38” x 26” playards perfectly, rounded corners and superior edge support create a snug fit into all 38” x 26” play yards every time. No risk of unsafe spaces or lost pacifiers, toys, or stuffed animals at the sides or corners of this playard pad. IMPORTANT: PLAYARDS COME IN MANY SIZES. The NICESURE pack and play pad is specifically designed for 38” x 26” playards ONLY.
  • DUAL SIDED FOAM FOR PACK AND PLAY: Optimal design for your growing baby’s developmental needs. Infant side offers the firmness that’s critical for newborns. And for toddlers, simply flip over to the plush, softer side featuring our CertiPUR-USA high-density memory foam for a softer play surface.
  • EXTRA THICK FOR SUPER COMFORT: Your sweet baby will not be a happy camper (nor will you) if her play yard pad lacks vital support and comfort when playing or even standing. That’s why our pack and play foam pad is very thick to offer deeper and more supportive comfort for your baby’s enjoyment during play or quiet time.
  • SUPER SAFE: Our ultra-soft Jacquard cover is hypoallergenic, our high-quality zipper permits easy removal for machine washing and drying.
  • PRODUCT DIMENSIONS: 38''L X26''W X3''T